Home Ask Arthur It is not a 19th century pendant!

It is not a 19th century pendant!


pix 1

Hi Arthur,

I have the pictures of my pendant here. I was hoping you would be able to help me to look at it to see if the piece is in fact an antique from the 19th century and maybe also provide a price estimate for the handiwork and jade quality. Thanks! 



Hi Casey

Sorry Casey, your pendant is not a 19th century antique jade. You have got yourself a lemon.

This is not even polymer impregnated jadeite jade. It is a type of composite material and you can find them in abundance in the Jade Market in Hong Kong or in China. A piece is sold at around HK$10, or US$1.30.

I am not sure about the clasp. If you set the gold clasp at a jewellery shop with this pendant I suggest you take it off, keep the gold and store away your ‘jade pendant’. If the clasp comes with the ‘jade’ then store it away.

It looks so cheap to be worn by a pretty lady.

pix 2

One has to be careful when a seller makes some ridiculous claim. Where did you buy this item? At a road side store in a back alley or some nook-and-corner street, a curio shop or even a jade speciality shop? Surely, this seller did not have the capacity to own a 19th century item.

pix 3

To make claims on the provenance of a jade article, you have to know something about the seller. If it is from an auction house of international repute, then it is safe to assume that thorough research work has been carried out to authenticate such claims.

In fact most sellers do not really have ‘antique’ jade, or jade worn by emperors or empresses of dynasties long gone, as they claimed to be. But a lot of buyers are taken in hook, line and sinker because the seller has the gift of the gap and can talk the hind legs off a donkey. Before one realize it, the item is being packed, money received and the buyer leaves with a euphoric feeling of getting a good deal from a sucker seller.

HK$10 a piece at the Jade market ...
HK$10 a piece at the Jade market …

Anyway, I too have been down that slippery road before. I have heard a lot of tales by sellers, and they were so convincing that I did not realize that I had been had until I recapped later what the seller said when he sold me the item.

But if it is not really a lot of money, then take it as an experience. You will get better in your jade shopping as you buy more fake or real items. You just have to enquire more and learn more about jade.

Best of wishes …


Previous articleI Am Back Again …
Next articleRare Blue Diamond Sold
I am a Graduate Gemologist trained at the Gemological Institute of America (GIA) in New York City, USA. I hold an MBA degree from Cranfield University, United Kingdom, and a Bachelor degree in Mathematics. My earlier profession was a banker until I found jade in Myanmar (Burma) in the early 90s. I have traveled to the fabled Hpakan Jade mines, and Mogok, the world’s famous rubies and sapphires mines in upper Burma, with my second son. Three of my children are also Graduate Gemologist, GIA, NYC and they deal in diamonds, gemstones and jade. 我是在美国纽约市的美国宝石学院(GIA)接受过培训的宝石研究学家。 我拥有英国克兰菲尔德大学的工商管理硕士学位和数学学士学位。我以前的职业是银行家,直到90年代初我在缅甸接触到玉石。我曾经和我的次子一起去过缅甸上流传说中的哈帕翡翠矿山和莫谷矿山, 莫谷矿山是世界上著名的红宝石和蓝宝石矿山。我的三个孩子都是纽约市GIA毕业的宝石研究学家, 他们专门处理钻石,宝石和玉石.